Tuesday, February 10, 2009

Marketing strategies for fast-moving consumer goods: UK Perspective

By Jan-Benedict E.M. Steenkamp & Marnik G. Dekimpe

The current recession is the most brutal economic downturn in a lifetime. One industry where the consequences of the recession are felt particularly hard is the fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG) industry. In the past, this industry was dominated by such well-known manufacturer brands as Ariel detergent, Nescafé coffee, Philadelphia cream cheese, Flora margarine, and Pampers nappies. However, in recent decades, so-called private labels or store brands – brands owned by retail giants such as Wal-Mart, Tesco, Carrefour and Aldi – have made huge inroads, especially in western Europe and the US. Today they control 20 per cent of the US FMCG market, 35 per cent in Germany, and more than 40 per cent in the UK Much of the loss of market share of manufacturer brands is initiated in economic downturns. Faced with a pressing need to save money, shoppers turn to (cheaper) store brands. They discover that the quality is good and, consequently, many stick with the brand when the economy improves again.

Our research, spanning several decades of purchasing behaviour and multiple recessions in countries across the globe, shows that the growth of private labels in recessions leaves permanent scars on manufacturer brands. Will it be any different this time? It is possible, but this will depend on how brand managers respond to the current downturn. Brands that take a proactive stance and treat the recession as an opportunity are likely to come out of the recession stronger than before. In this article, we describe what they should do. Two issues drive the outcome of how brands make it through the recession: their equity at the onset of the recession; and investments in the brand during the recession.

Brand equity
How strong is your brand? Is it a brand with many loyal buyers that people know and trust and are willing to pay a price premium for? Or is it a weak brand, commanding little loyalty and esteem? In sum, is your brand equity high or low? Strong brands enter the recession in a much more favourable position than weak brands. They are on the shelves of more retailers, have more shelf space and have a larger and more committed customer base. Marketing budgets for stronger brands also tend to be higher.

In recessions, retailers across the world devote more shelf space to their own brands (especially since they also command a higher margin). For example, to cater to the increased price sensitivity of UK consumers in the wake of the economic downturn, Tesco launched on September 17 2008, its fourth line of private labels, called “Discount Brands at Tesco.” Sales of Tesco’s discount and value ranges are up 65 per cent on last year, and one in four shoppers now purchases these ranges. This puts a pressure on the number of national brands the retailer still carries. Retailers are less likely to kill brands with a strong and loyal customer base.

High-equity brands are also better insulated against the switching to private labels behaviour that is ubiquitous in recessions, if only because loyal customers incur higher switching costs when buying non-preferred items. High-equity brands are known to suffer less, and to recover faster, following a product-harm crisis. The same holds true when faced with an economic crisis.

Brand investments in recessions
In recessions, shoppers have a natural tendency to switch to private labels in order to save money. The logical thing for brands to do is to counter this tendency by either lowering their own price, or by offering sufficient non-price reasons to consumers to buy their brand. Our research, spanning more than two decades of actual marketing behaviour, reveals that most brands do exactly the opposite. First, brands can counter the price advantage of private labels by ramping up their own price promotions (temporary price reductions). Consumers are more price-sensitive in recessions, so offering more price promotions makes a lot of sense. Surprisingly, price promotion activity for most brands actually decreases in recessionary times.

Second, the brand can counter the price advantage of private labels by increasing its investments in advertising or new product activity. Both provide non-price reasons to purchase the manufacturer brand – image and improved functional performance, respectively. However, our research shows that advertising and innovation activity decreases in recessions.

Marketing research is also one of the first victims in a recession. These outlays are discretionary, and offer an easy way to reduce costs. Unfortunately, in bad economic times, it is more difficult to convince consumers to buy your higher-priced brand. Optimal matching of your brand with consumer needs is even more necessary in difficult times, but evidence shows that brand manufacturers prefer to operate without this crucial guidance during recessions.

Why do companies manage brands in such a counterproductive way? After all, their brands are their most valuable assets. Cutting back in recessions on price promotions, innovation activity and advertising saves money in the short term, but undermines the long-term equity of brands. We believe that it is due to a toxic combination of short-term perspective that characterises the decision-making of many managers and the tremendous pressure on the bottom line in recessionary times. The easiest way out is to cut costs, and since price promotions, advertising, new product introductions and marketing research are largely discretionary costs, they can easily be cut in the short term.

However, this behaviour weakens the equity of brands and negatively impacts on shareholder value. We studied the stock price performance of 26 global companies over a 25-year period and found that annual growth in shareholder value for companies that do not tie their advertising investments to the business cycle is 1.3 per cent higher compared with companies that do let their advertising investments depend on the business cycle. This translates into billions of dollars of shareholder value that are destroyed annually by adopting this erroneous practice.

In sum, companies often do the wrong thing by reducing marketing expenditure despite compelling evidence that it pays to not follow the general trend of cutting back during a recession. Put differently, one should start to treat those marketing expenses as strategic investments, rather than as short-run costs that can easily be cut when the going gets tough. Note that “going against the trend” can be in absolute terms (strong form) or in relative terms (weak form). Indeed, by holding brand expenditures at pre-recessionary levels, while other brands spend less, one may still increase one’s share of total market communications.

Four scenarios
By combining two dimensions of brand equity at the onset of the recession and brand investments in the recession, we get four scenarios.

1> Brand Equity (High), Reduction in brand investments: High Loss Potential
2> Brand Equity (High), No reduction/increase in brand investments: Recession is opportunity
3> Brand Equity (Low), Reduction in brand investments: Survival game
4> Brand Equity (Low), No reduction/increase in brand investments: Double or nothing

Brands in cell (1) run the distinct danger that their equity will be significantly eroded in the current recession. They start from a favourable position, but their behaviour will lead to a significant weakening of their position vis-à-vis private labels and the brands in cell (2). Managerial decision-making for these brands is overly cautious and focused on the short-term. These brands should emphasise activities that keep their customers satisfied (and, hence, retain them), rather than focus on cost-saving activities. Indeed, customers lost during the recession may never come back, even when the economy’s outlook improves again.

For brands in cell (2), the recession is an opportunity to pull ahead of their short-sighted competitors in cell (1). Their proactive behaviour will strengthen their (relative) position, not only in the recession period, but also in subsequent years. Brands in cell (3) are in the worst possible situation: they start weak, and their management makes the wrong decisions. They are prime candidates to be de-listed by retailers who are pushing their private labels in recessions – and many of them will. Their brand equity will decline, and many will not even survive the recession.

The brands in cell (4) have the opportunity of a lifetime to fight back. They start in an unfavourable position – their equity is low and, in normal times, it would take tremendous marketing investments to break through the competitive clutter. However, given that most brands cut back in recessions (and, hence, belong to cells (1) and (3), brands in cell (4) are able to increase their share of total market communication in the category dramatically by maintaining or – even better – increasing their marketing investments. But it is a risky strategy – if it is poorly executed, the anticipated increase in sales and profits will not materialise and the brand may be discontinued.

Conclusion
Just as slumps in the stock market offer great opportunities for courageous investors, slumps in the real economy offer great opportunities to courageous managers. All evidence indicates that a proactive strategy is associated with increased brand success and shareholder value. If you wait till the good times come back, you ignore the advice given by the legendary ice hockey player Wayne Gretzky: “I skate to where the puck is going to be, not to where it has been.” Recessions are not for the faint-hearted but who said that fair weather makes great managers?

Authors: Jan-Benedict E.M. Steenkamp (jbs@unc.edu) is C. Knox Massey Distinguished Professor of Marketing and Marketing Area Chair, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, U.S.A. & Executive Director of AiMark, and author (with N. Kumar) of the book Private Label Strategy: How to Meet the Store Brand Challenge. Marnik G. Dekimpe (m.g.dekimpe@uvt.nl) is Research Professor of Marketing, Tilburg University, the Netherlands and Professor of Marketing, Catholic University Leuven, Belgium

Labels:

17 Comments:

Blogger shankar said...

Dear Nitin,

We are a new company, base in Mumbai getting into manufacturing and distribution of personal care products, have a Strong R&D backing from a US based company.

We are looking at setting up our distribution network across key markets, request you to revert with your contact details so that we can discuss and take this ahead.

Look forward to here from you.shankarshinde2020@gmail.com

Regards,
Shankar

February 18, 2009 12:13 PM  
Blogger Ajay Khaitan said...

MASS ADVERTISING @ Rs 1/-

I have invented a Wonder Corporate
Gift @ Rs 1/- to attract more than
10 Crore people in no time.

Ideal for Free Schemes, Mass
Publicity & Brand Image Making,
A must for FMCGs, Corporate
Houses & Advertising Agencies.

Ajay Kumar Khaitan,
Mob: 09933115511
microwonder@gmail.com

June 07, 2009 6:05 PM  
Blogger Unknown said...

Thanks for this information.. But this time I want to know some information regarding ACROSS Medical Disposables company profile. I want to promote my website on the first page ranking in search engines. Please give your suggestions.

ACROSS Medical Disposables company profile

December 10, 2011 9:33 AM  
Blogger Unknown said...

A good one for business community can gain the knowledge for this blog.
Virginia Beach Dentist

June 13, 2012 6:22 PM  
Blogger TALLENT said...

Very good blog and great information is here.
dentist toronto
Boca Raton Dentist
San Clemente Dentist

July 28, 2012 4:41 PM  
Blogger Unknown said...

Informative blog written. Marketing analysis is also one of the first affected in a financial downturn. These outlays are optional, and provide an easy way to reduce cost.Maximum related of your product with customer needs is even more necessary in hardships, but proof reveals that product producers want to function without this essential assistance during recessions.

Market Analysis Report

December 25, 2012 11:47 AM  
Blogger Ram Katariya said...

Stock tips from Epic Research for traders to get huge earnings in Stock market. We also provide proper recommendations and advices on all segments in share market.

July 12, 2016 3:53 PM  
Blogger Unknown said...

Really ,This is a wonderful post.Thanks for sharing this important information.

PR Agency | Digitla Marketing Services | Languages Translation Services.

August 09, 2016 2:37 PM  
Blogger The Yellow Coin Communication said...

Thank you for publishing this valuable information. this is a

great blog.

Top PR

Agency in Delhi
| Digitla Marketing Services | Social Media Services

December 30, 2016 12:58 PM  
Blogger Unknown said...

For marketing you can use mobile marketing also. Now a days SMS marketing is best for reaching targeted audience with cost effectively. There is some very good Bulk SMS Company which are providing good services.

February 27, 2017 5:59 PM  
Blogger Abella Rez said...

I read your Digital Marketing post.really excellent detailed Information.this is good post..thank you for share this post.but we provide best webdesign & Digital Marketing service for low cost.

website development in gurgaon

July 24, 2018 3:37 PM  
Blogger Celia Dave said...

I was diagnosed with stage 3 breast cancer in August 2010. A valuable friend told me about Dr. Itua Herbal Center in West Africa. She gave me her phone number and email address. I quickly contacted him to guarantee that his herbal medicines will heal my cancer and I will heal forever I said OK.I ask him what is the healing process, he asks me to pay the fees I did and within 7 working days he sent me the herbal medicine and then he asked me I told my friend Gomez about the herbal drug so that he gave me to go and drink it.So after drinking for two weeks, I was cured, I am so grateful and I promise that I will do it I recommend to anyone who has cancer and that that I am doing. Herbal medicine Dr. Itua makes me believe that there is hope for people with Parkinson's disease, schizophrenia, cancer, scoliosis, bladder cancer, colorectal cancer, breast cancer and breast cancer. kidney cancer. , Leukemia, lung cancer, skin cancer, uterine cancer, prostate cancer Fibromyalgia, a
Fibrodysplasia Syndrome, Epilepsy,Sclerosis sickness, Dupuytren's Disease, Diabetes, Celiac Disease, Angiopathy, Ataxia, Arthritis, Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis, Alzheimer's Disease, Lupus, Adrenocortic Carcinoma.Asthma, Allergic Diseases.HIV Help, HIV Aids, Herpes, Disease Chronic inflammatory, Memory disorder,
Here is his contact information ...... [Email ... drituaherbalcenter@gmail.com. Whatsapp ... + 2348149277967]

August 31, 2019 11:45 AM  
Blogger Esha Agrawal said...


Great details share. Before investing in market I must say stock broker are very important to earn profit.

Open Demat Account with Indira Securities best Stock Broker
Open Commodity Trading Account
Open equity Trading Account
Mobile Trading App

April 22, 2020 5:27 PM  
Blogger Jessica Morgan said...

Dr Abumere herbal medicine is a good remedy for herpes simplex virus cure. My name is Mary Fredrick ,I just want to share this article about Dr Abumere who helped me, i want to inform the public how i was cured from (HERPES SIMPLEX VIRUS) by DR Abumere, i visited different hospital but they gave me list of drugs like Familiar , Zovirax, and Valtrex which is very expensive to treat the symptoms and never cured me. I was browsing through the Internet searching for remedy on HERPES and i saw comment of people talking about how DR Abumere cured them, when i contacted him he gave me hope and send a Herbal medicine to me that i took and it seriously worked for me, am a free person now without any problem, my HERPES result came out negative, I pray to God to never let me and my family forget you in our life,i am now cured permanently.you can also get your self cured, if you really need this dr's help,you can reach him now email: doctorabumere6@gmail.com. com Or whats app +2349021975055This is real,He also has herbal cure for the Following DISEASES, eczema,urethra wart,chronic problems.Herpes, Cancer, Als,Hepatitis, Diabetes, HPV,Infections,ulcer ETC 

May 12, 2020 8:11 PM  
Blogger Shruti said...

Movies Trending Now
Movies Trending Now
Movies Trending Now
Movies Trending Now
Movies Trending Now
Movies Trending Now
Movies Trending Now

August 11, 2020 7:32 AM  
Blogger Nidhi Singh said...

Thanks admin for the post, Its really a nice post and Looking for more blogs like this. Please stay updated..!

Corporate strategy consultant in USA

January 05, 2021 3:12 PM  
Blogger Unknown said...

Thank you for sharing this fast-moving consumer goods blog.

March 12, 2021 12:47 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home